Q&A: Love the Person, Hate the Sin

Q&A: Love the Person, Hate the Sin

Many people struggle with how to love others, especially when they’ve hurt you. In this episode, Fr. Ben, Silvia, and Khira address this struggle by remembering that we are called to love the person but hate the sin.

Many people struggle with how to love others, especially when they've hurt you. In this episode, Fr. Ben, Silvia, and Khira address this struggle by remembering that we are called to love the person but hate the sin.

[00:00:01] Hey everybody welcome the Soul Food Priest podcast of Father Ben as always it's wonderful to have you and I'm here with Kira and Sylvia. Hey guys Hola Hola, hola Hoy va a ser en español Claro que si, no problema Si que si Si Kira Si Tu puedes entendernos Claro que si Bienvenidos a Comida para el alma Never mind, we're gonna stop right here I couldn't even translate La comida para el alma

[00:00:30] Yeah I think so I know English is better Yeah I have no clue There you go Yeah but you did study Spanish I mean you tell me you studied it Like in high school did you take Spanish? Yeah There you go It was like three years but it wasn't Okay You're professional ¿Donde esta el baño? You know what that means right? Professional like kindergarten level Spanish Yeah Like not even that because Okay here's my thing with language I really wish they would teach languages

[00:00:58] on a conversational level first and then grammar I'm terrible with English grammar but I can speak I mean not perfectly all the time My husband corrects me all the time when I'm like yeah me and the kids did this Uh excuse me You know Anyways So I'm terrible at grammar but I can still speak the language Same with Spanish Well that's actually a good point I think That's a good point Like if they started with grammar But then Cause that's how you learn as a kid Right

[00:01:27] And like for instance we know plenty of of kids that grew up in Hispanic households that fail Spanish Yeah But they're fluent in Spanish Yeah But they fail it And so the question is usually cause they don't know the grammar Because the grammar And also I mean And they always teach grammar first and then the language I almost talked to the president of the United States in the 90s when I was taking Spanish Well no 2000s Oh yeah Nice Yeah Because I'm fluent and yet

[00:01:55] we don't live in Europe Why are you teaching me Spain Spanish the way they speak it in Spain In Spain Makes no sense We live next to Mexico Can you teach me Yeah Mexican Spanish? Yeah Because if you talk to somebody in Spain Spanish in the United States They're not gonna know what you're talking about No one's gonna know what you're talking about

[00:02:27] There's no over the years that speak Spain Spanish Yeah And like the Vosotros form for instance Yes And no one speaks this Yeah And so like Yeah I mean Just think about it Besides that they have the lisp thing Yeah And I'm like Yeah It's pretty sexy though It just kinda rubs I like it It is interesting It is very different See that Como estas Yeah right Like But I mean I'm gonna be honest

[00:02:55] When I'm talking to somebody with the Spain The Spain Spanish lisp Yeah It's really hard for me to not start laughing Yeah I mean it really is Barcelona Now if like Cristiano Ronaldo is speaking to me I'm not gonna laugh No I mean Yeah Right I mean He The guy is pretty cool Yeah he's pretty cool Keep speaking That's how it is when Soccer yes Like when you I mean that's why everybody loves French Because it's such a beautiful melodic

[00:03:25] Yeah Language Yeah There's other languages like Dutch or German Where people are like I don't know about that Yeah But like the It seems to be more choppy and stuff I mean Italian it's great Yeah Italian I think it's better than Spanish Yeah I think so Portuguese is really interesting Because Portuguese is like In my opinion Because I don't speak any Portuguese But like I've noticed they have this sound J Like they'll have J A lot Like And that's how I can usually tell

[00:03:55] If they're speaking Portuguese Not Spanish Uh huh Yeah Is they like Yeah they just have this It's like a Frenchy Spanish Right Yeah I love it It's interesting A Frenchy Spanish Yeah Yeah this I think we were talking about Do you remember what my favorite food is? I do I'll let you tell us again You remember Kira right? We were talking about this not long ago French Oh it is the It's gotta be French No Indian

[00:04:24] No Indian food Yeah I knew it It's my fave Wait I thought it was the potatoes The what? The French potatoes No I Overall Oh overall The cuisine The Indian cuisine is my favorite Oh oh Yeah Not your favorite dish Yeah sorry Sorry I was thinking your favorite dish Which is the potatoes Dolphin yeah Yes Well I got the Indian one okay We all We both got the point Very good Very good Yeah that is definitely my favorite dish Indian food is my favorite

[00:04:54] Oh no No Can't do that Yeah it's although I have had menudo that actually I thought Italian was your favorite Uh uh Indian No Indian But you wanna be Italian I mean I love Italians And I love Italy But Indian food is hands down my favorite food He told me that but he told me he wanted to be Mexican That's true Yeah He just I mean Look there's not a human being alive Know your audience That does not love Mexican food Oh yeah I mean it's impossible to go wrong with that It's impossible Yeah they So and we're talking about languages Yeah

[00:05:23] And you probably know this so that Of a billion people in India And literally hundreds of languages Like the people I know from Kerala Which is in the southern part of India They're the At minimum They speak four languages each Wow Minimum And they are not If you talk to them they'll say they're not remotely related They're fully different language They're not a dialect They're full different languages Wow And so my

[00:05:50] One of my favorite favorite cookbooks of all time Is it's called Lord Krishna's Cuisine By a woman named Yamuna Devi Okay And so she It's It's all vegetarian And I do eat meat But I spent several years as a vegetarian And that book is probably three inches thick And I think I've made two inches of them Of that book Wow

[00:06:18] And so that book is fantastic She was friends with you know the Beatles for a long time Got into the Hinduism Uh huh Right when the special and they were doing Sergeant Peppers Yeah And so they went to India And studied Hare Krishna Okay So Yamuna Devi was working with George Harrison and them at that time Look at that So she came back years later She wrote this cookbook It's a fantastic cookbook She died in 2011 But

[00:06:49] But that had That type of cuisine Had a big impact as you can imagine On Gandhi Yeah And Gandhi died in January of 48 1948 Mm-hmm And he was what we would call Mm-hmm Like a vegan Mm-hmm Uh macrobiotic kind of diet Basically no meat, no fish, no dairy Mm-hmm Lots of grains, lots of nuts, lots of fruit Mm-hmm And um He would often drink a lot of hot water Mm-hmm

[00:07:18] And uh And come in like somebody would drink hot tea Yeah But one of the things that he said He had Gandhi quoted St. Augustine And St. Augustine kind of coined this phrase But he said that we love the person but we hate the sin Mm-hmm So Gandhi picked up on that from Augustine And so we sometimes hear that in our own time Mm-hmm Especially with

[00:07:44] You know, Father, what do I do if it's Christmas My children are coming home with their spouses And my son wants to come stay in my house with his live-in girlfriend Mm-hmm What do I do? Mm-hmm Yeah Mm-hmm This happens, same thing happens with someone's partner They're same-sex attracted Yeah Mm-hmm So they're asking these questions What do we do? What do we not? And you see everything on the full side Yeah Absolutely not

[00:08:14] Sure, of course And so what do we do? So priests get these questions an awful lot Yeah Especially around the holidays Mm-hmm And so But But like In 5th century Augustine You know, this is what he said How do we love the person? But we can also say that this or that behavior is just wrong Yeah And then how do we relate to that person? Mm-hmm So it's something we're always trying to figure out

[00:08:42] I mean, there's usually no black and white We're all kind of making it up I love this person On the other hand I don't want a green light what they're doing Mm-hmm And so it's kind of a push-pull thing Mm-hmm Yeah Would you agree or not? Because I've always had this question Are we participating in the sin if we don't speak up? At least say and then respect

[00:09:05] Are we, I guess, participating in agreeing or not even saying, hey, I think that you should go this route If we were like, hey, cool, yeah, I'm fine with that Yeah Are we participating in that sin or are we not responsible at all? Because I think we have, if I'm correct, the responsibility to take God's word everywhere we go with everybody Mm-hmm So kind of tell us how Yeah Yeah, it's a really good question, Sylvia

[00:09:33] So if we read the Catechism of the Catholic Church under the section of sin, it would definitely say in the affirmative your question Mm-hmm And it makes the point, whether people like it or not, whether they agree with it or not, Catholic doctrine makes the point that we actually can participate in the sin and in some cases be responsible for it Yeah

[00:09:58] So I'll give you an example, in 1930, the Pope at the time, his name was Pope Pius XI He wrote a document called On Christian Marriage, Costi Canubii Mm-hmm

[00:10:11] And in this point, in this encyclical, he says to priests, he said, look, if you fail to talk to these people, these couples, out of fear, God's gonna hold you accountable for what they do 100% Which is Ezekiel chapter 3 in the Old Testament

[00:10:33] And so, yeah, to answer your question, now the question is, okay, if that's true, what is a way that I can do this that's not gonna further alienate me from this person Yeah That's gonna be honest and not make it exponentially worse So therein lies the question, yes, we have to sometimes say something

[00:10:55] This is, not to go off into this, but this is, I get so passionate about this because the, so many of the priests of my generation and the generation before me and the generation before that They understood, they really misunderstood what the word pastoral means or walking with our brothers and sisters Mm-hmm

[00:11:20] And I get it, they wanna meet people where they're at, but so many have interpreted the word being a pastoral priest as I just say nothing And I'm not gonna say that there's anything wrong with this Yeah I'm gonna love them, but in loving them, I'm not gonna say one thing about the behavior being wrong Mm-hmm, yeah

[00:11:39] So it's a gross misunderstanding of what genuine pastoral behavior from a, especially from a Catholic priest or church leader involves truth Mm-hmm, mm-hmm, keritas and veritate, truth and love Yeah So we, they, that was, that's been a huge malignancy Yeah

[00:12:03] And the Catholic priesthood for several generations now is a deep misunderstanding of what pastoral means And, you know, and I always tell people, look, I want you to get to heaven, but I wanna get there too Yeah So look, I'm gonna be honest with you, if you don't listen, okay, that's cool, but that's on you, bro Mm-hmm, mm-hmm, okay That's why the responsibility is also on, you know, I'm looking out for my soul, I'm looking out for the soul of my spouse

[00:12:31] And my brothers and sisters, but, hey, I'm looking out for mine too Mm-hmm, mm-hmm, so by telling you, yes, I love you, so I'm just like, don't say anything Cause, you know, you're gonna, mm-hmm, mm-hmm, you know, tear them away Or they're not gonna be close to you anymore, but I also have to look out for myself And, if you know, they can be like, cool, love you, respect you It's hard It is It's hard to, especially if you're a people pleaser Yeah And, you know, there's a lot of us out there, but you can be loving Yeah

[00:12:59] And, uh, you can say it many times Maybe that first time, and you wait a little while, and you say it again, and then you throw it in there Yeah And then find ways, and sometimes life is going to help you That's right In the process of Yeah They might have something going on, and it's like, oh, let me get close to Jesus That's right That's when you go in and say remember Right He's always been there with you So, life sometimes helps us, um, help those that need to hear more about Jesus and his teachings

[00:13:27] So, don't give up, but be gentle That's a really good point Yeah, it's humbling, life Yeah And then, you know, we've talked about the culture, you know, I think the culture is making this more difficult Because the culture, uh, no longer knows how to separate the, the person from their actions Mm-hmm Um, and, and so, because, because it's just all intertwined

[00:13:53] So, how I behave, what I say, what I do, is part of who I am So, therefore, if you tell me that what I'm doing is wrong, then you're telling me I'm wrong That's right And that I'm bad And that I don't have dignity When that's not what is, and so there's that, that, that distorted belief between the two things Mm-hmm Um, that, that we have to, we have to divorce the action from the person Mm-hmm

[00:14:21] That all people are, people are created with dignity, and are good And so, our identity at its core is always good However, we can be tempted to act in a wrong way, and not in accordance with our dignity And so, therefore, should I be called out for those wrong actions? Yes, but that does not mean that, you know, if I, if I, if I'm telling one of my kids Okay, what you just said, that was wrong

[00:14:51] They should not take it as, well, now I'm a bad person Yeah Yeah No, what you, your actions, I, I've, even in parenting, I've emphasized this so much with my own kids That you are good, that action was wrong Yeah What you said was wrong, you need to make amends for that You need to apologize for that, but yet you're still good And then you, you show them that they're continually good by, okay, you've made a mistake I'm still going to love you, I'm still going to embrace you Yeah I'm still going to take care of you

[00:15:18] So they can, so that that is further solidified in their brains That we make mistakes, we do wrong things, but I can't condone your bad behavior Yeah, that's right As people shouldn't condone my bad behavior either But, but we, but our culture, you know, we talk about tolerance and all of that Well, tolerance is accept all of my actions Yeah, that's right, that's right, that's how they interpret

[00:15:43] Yeah, that's how they, that's how you tolerate me, is accepting all of me, including my actions Yeah But, but no, they're, your, your actions, and you know, and our actions should derive from the good place in us You know, I mean, even Jesus says that, it all comes from your heart So if our heart is off, and not connected to God, our actions are going to reveal that Yeah If our heart is in tune with God, our actions are going to reveal that

[00:16:13] And, and so it's, and so ultimately what we're trying to say is, is I want you to experience love on such a deep level Yeah And know you are loved in such a deeper way than just purely what you say You're like, you're loved way more deeply than that And, and you want them to know that deep love Yeah, especially as a parent, right?

[00:16:39] Yeah, yeah, which is why you, why you have to, you know, I think kind of keep, continuously step in and say No, like, this shouldn't happen because you are loved even deeper Like, you're, you're made for more All of us are made for more than just these base animalistic actions When you speak about your kids, to my mind it comes up, you know, all, all of our children are different So that means all of our friends and other people that we know are completely different And how they receive advice or anything is different

[00:17:09] So you, you can't go to this person and tell them a certain way and go to this one and tell them the exact same way You know, they're, they're different personalities in how they receive things So what comes to my mind is, you know, the big responsibility that we have Yes, we got to start with our families, start with our children, start with our friends But the importance of knowing your faith when you're doing these things Because someone can come back to you and say, but isn't your Lord all merciful? And he's going to forgive no matter what He's going to love me no matter what So know your faith

[00:17:37] You know, you want to help your sisters out, your brothers out You have to know where you're coming from You just can't be, well, God wants you to be different Why? And then you don't know So that's what The big importance of that 100% Yeah, I think you, you guys make great points I mean, that's, they sometimes call it the four levels of intelligence, right? Under the umbrella of wisdom People tend to, they can go around wisdom in different ways By my own mistakes, watching other people make mistakes

[00:18:06] But under the umbrella of wisdom, they typically would say emotional intelligence People that are attuned to what's going on emotionally People in the room, my spouse, my children, coworkers Academic intelligence, they're smart Practical intelligence, they know how to do things, get things done I can change a tire, I can put up a shower curtain I know how to get stuff done, right? And then spiritual intelligence So ideally we're growing in all four of those

[00:18:36] But typically we've, to your point, we've all known people that are prayerful people They have spiritual intelligence But they don't have a level of academic intelligence To defend their faith If somebody dumps this in their lab, right? And, whereas we know people that are academic And they have academic intelligence that lack basic common sense I mean, they, and so So, we're ideally growing in all these to some extent

[00:19:06] All the time And, but I do think, as we're talking about Like the question kind of becomes As Keir was alluding to Okay, if this is me and my child What would be a very, a prudent way to address this issue? If it comes up at Thanksgiving, at Christmas At my 25th wedding anniversary

[00:19:33] If they want to come and stay with their live-in, whoever Okay? And, and so, my own take Because I get this a lot And, and priests do I said, look, if you want my humble opinion I would say it once Give them a bit of boundary But as a general rule, we want presence over pressure In other words, that's kind of the phrase that I sometimes use with them Presence over pressure

[00:20:02] We don't want to be finger-waggy Because that generally does not yield good fruit But we, there's, it's, it is good to say Honey, you know, you know that your father and I love you And we wish you only the best But there's going to be children here And I can't have you staying with your live-in girlfriend At Christmas And so we're normalizing this Okay? Well, if you don't accept her Then you don't accept me And I don't want to be here And blah, blah, blah

[00:20:31] So, we have to be willing to take that on the chin Yeah, yeah If we're making a boundary Because they're not going to like it Yeah, yeah On the other hand, you've got a worse situation If, fast forward a year from now If you have a six-year-old that's seeing this And they're like, wait, what? What's, what's going on here? Yeah So, I get it It's messy And it's uncomfortable As you said Sometimes for people that hate confrontation

[00:21:00] But my experience is always better to have those hard conversations up front Yes Because after you When you pull back You can't get that back again Yeah Yeah You can't get it back again Yeah And it's important to remember That if we push somebody away Because of us trying to make them Not better, but closer to Jesus It's okay sometimes Yeah, that's right It's okay That's right Sometimes we have to hold firm

[00:21:29] And in a very respectful, kind, loving way Never being disrespectful Uh-huh But if they push away It's okay Uh-huh And sometimes we feel terrible for that It's because of me that they're no longer close to us Well, remember the reason why Yeah And it's okay And hopefully God will bring them back around Life will bring them back around Yeah And always be Never be that I told you Right Never do that Never

[00:21:59] No question Always be ready to open them Uh-huh Open that door with big, wide arms And welcome back Yeah, totally Well said And Jesus, you know In today's Gospel You know, it's A man isn't welcomed in his own Yeah In his own town You know, amongst his own family Or his own friends You know, so it's It's that whole idea of You know, people look at all of a sudden and go Wait, but you were the one Yeah Way back when Who did this, that, and the other How are you

[00:22:28] Why are you the one that's telling me what to do Yeah We run up against that a lot too Yeah And you know And I was listening to a reflection by Jeff Cavins And you know, he was like You just kind of like you say You have these hard conversations right up front You acknowledge it Yeah Like, yeah I did do that And I am so sorry I was I acted like a total jerk at that point in time And I am so sorry And I just want to make sure that that's cleared up You know, I mean Yeah You accept and you own those

[00:22:58] Yeah Those actions that were wrong And that hurt other people Yeah And you try to move beyond that Yeah Because that's Those good actions are what are really going to speak Yeah Yeah That's really where the new evangelization is taking place Is it's not just all talk and here's I know my faith But now I'm going to try to live it authentically And And yeah, that means I do make mistakes And I am going to make mistakes And I did make mistakes

[00:23:26] But I'm going to own up to those things And apologize And try to And I'm going to be working every single day To try to grow stronger Because I was listening this morning To Dr. Arthur Brooks Mentioning him again And And he was like You know, the Life is a gym You know, this Going to the gym is hard And if you are continually trying to work out

[00:23:55] You're going to reach those points where you're like I can't do it anymore This is hard And you fail But that's actually really good Because that's where you start to become stronger Is when you hit those failure points Or when you hit those points where you're weak And you realize I'm weak But you either try to persevere or you stop And then you think Okay, well now I know how I need to improve And how I need to get better And what more I need to do And so

[00:24:23] And so our life is like that spiritual gem too And an interpersonal gem Where it's Yeah, I recognize my weaknesses And I'm going to try to do the right things to rectify them And then I'm going to continue to hit the gym again And keep going And praise God When it does happen Because then I'm going to grow in humility even more That's what I was like And that kind of gives a person more authority

[00:24:52] When we're speaking from experience And you're right, we throw it on the table Yeah And there's always mercy But truth with mercy It's kind of both ends It's like two lungs breathing together Hey, listen, don't forget Put soul in your food And give food to your soul God bless you