Doubting Thomas in Reverse

Doubting Thomas in Reverse

On this episode, Meagan and Chris discuss the fascinating Catholic tradition of "Doubting Thomas in Reverse" focussed around the Assumption of our Blessed Mother. It is really fascinating.

(Full Disclosure we recorded this episode a few months ago, but failed to get it posted, but it is worth the wait......)

On this episode, Meagan and Chris discuss the fascinating Catholic tradition of "Doubting Thomas in Reverse" focussed around the Assumption of our Blessed Mother. It is really fascinating.

(Full Disclosure we recorded this episode a few months ago, but failed to get it posted, but it is worth the wait......)

[00:00:00] Is your garage door off track? Is it closing crooked? Or is it making unusual sounds? Call Lift Doctors. They're on duty seven days a week serving the Memphis and Germantown community. From Broken Springs to new installations, Lift Doctors offers same-day service in most situations. With upfront pricing, no service fees, weekend fees, or emergency fees, Lift Doctors will get your garage back on track and at the right price.

[00:00:27] Lift Doctors enjoys a five-star Google rating and is standing by to help you today. Give them a call at 901-231-9449 or visit liftdrs.com. Memphis is built on strong communities and thoughtful design helps those communities thrive. For more than 50 years, A&F Architects has partnered with local organizations to create meaningful spaces throughout our city.

[00:00:55] Our work can be seen all across Memphis, from the Overton Park Bike Gate and the Overton Park Shell to works at the University of Memphis, St. Louis Catholic School, and a dozen other local churches. We are also proud partners of FedEx, International Paper, St. Jude, Baptist Memorial Hospital, and the Baptist Medical Group.

[00:01:17] If you're planning a renovation, expansion, or new facility, A&F Architects is ready to bring your vision to life. Learn more at anfa.com. Welcome to Buttered Toast and the Holy Ghost, where we love to serve up the weird but wonderful slices of Catholic tradition. Now, here's my mom and dad, Megan and Chris.

[00:01:48] Welcome to Butter Toast and the Holy Ghost. I'm Chris. And I remain Megan. Hey, remain Megan. Our dear listeners, thank you so much. It has been a few weeks since we recorded. We are so... For those of you who don't go to confession lately, like that was literally the cadence you say to the priest, it's been a few weeks since my last confession. Since our last recording. Hey, you know what? What is this but a confession of the faith, right? Yeah, sure. Isn't that profession of the faith? Okay.

[00:02:17] As long as I'm just checking to make sure I'm not crazy. We're excited to be back. We apologize. We had some illness and injury in the family. All is good now. I may have to... Joe's got to like really, really put a lot of editing work in. I'll cough from time to time, but we're 100% here. We're excited to be here. We've missed everybody. The kids are fine too. So just... Yes. I don't know if anybody's head went to like, oh my God, is everything okay? Does anyone here remember we have kids? I guess a lot of people know us in real life. Oh, you know. All right. Enough groveling.

[00:02:44] You know, we'll get you back on track. We'll get things. That's right. We have Joe at our back. Yeah. So we're going to be doing great. Well, I am excited to talk about what we have to talk about today. What do we have to talk about today? So this is another listener request. It is always really exciting to think that we have listeners. It's a few weeks late. Sorry, last time I'm groveling. But it is timely because I did look it up. Chris and I were actually debating about this right before the show about whether and which St. Thomas was recently, recently had a feast day.

[00:03:14] So you were confused because I had sent a meme in our chat about St. Thomas more, right? Like it was like listing off saints. And then it went, but wait, there's more. That was the meme. But his feast day was like the 22nd or 23rd of June. St. Thomas the Apostle, who we are talking about today, was the 3rd of July. So do you remember when we went to that barbecue at my dad's house and he was like, it's okay to eat meat today because it's a solemnity of St. Thomas? That's why this is going to be kind of timely.

[00:03:43] I wish I'd done it like a week before because then it'd be perfect. But we're not going to let perfect be the enemy of good. Yeah. So this is, it was the right St. Thomas. I wasn't crazy. Also, time has no meaning for me right now. So you're in the thick of it. June 22nd, July 3rd, whatever. They're close together. Like in all fairness. Three days apart. What are you talking about? Well, not quite three days, but hey, at least you're cute. No. Wow. We're talking about St. Thomas the Apostle today indirectly. Indirectly.

[00:04:11] We are talking about St. Thomas in reverse or doubting Thomas in reverse is sometimes what it's called. Or. Is that where he walks out of the room? It's a great question. Or the holy girdle. We're going to tie that all together. Girdle pun intended. But that's what. So you have so many questions on your face and I cannot wait to answer them. So this is a listener request. A request. Specifically, if we'd ever heard of or if we had any opinion on whether or not this is like a thing. So I did go down a bit of a rabbit hole as usual. Rabbit holes are the best. I had never even heard of this.

[00:04:40] So I'm really thankful that listener reached out. This is where like the true breadth and depth of the faith is astounding. Because you could like research your entire life and there'd be whole like cultural pieces or legends or traditions that like you'd never even have heard of. Just thinking about how like why the universal church really is. It's crazy to me. So this was something I had never heard of, but now I see it everywhere. So hopefully it'll be like that for you too. I'm excited. So I mentioned the girdle. The holy girdle. What do you think this is related to?

[00:05:09] I have no idea. No clue. I don't even know where to start with this. Do you know what a girdle is? I think I know what it is. What is a girdle, Joe? Isn't it like a belt? Well, I'm thinking, does this have anything to do with the washing of the feet? No, but it is something like that. So that's a good guess. When you put the towel on, I think they called it like a girdle or something. Maybe. A girdle is something you... I was going to say it's like gird your loins, right? Yes. It's a thing. It's like a cincture is another word for it. It's another word for cincture. Okay. So kind of like a belt. Yeah.

[00:05:39] It's something you tie around. And like it also can refer to like a belt in like I think the 1800s or something. But it comes from like you said to gird your loins, to ready yourself, like something you tie up. This is actually directly related to the assumption, which I'm sure you didn't realize that's where that was going. Not even in the slightest. So this has to do with Mother Mary. I'm really excited to share that. So now you're going to see this everywhere. So for those who are not as familiar, the assumption, just quick like definition, it's dogma, basically infallible teaching related to Mary,

[00:06:08] that she was assumed, taken up into heaven, body and soul, that something we're required to believe rather than left here on earth to experience normal human decay. This has to do with her fulfillment as a new Eve. We could talk about the assumption all day long. I don't want to get too in-depth in it today because we're going to focus on the doubting Thomas in reverse piece. But it's important that you kind of know where it's coming from because it's going to be a key element of this particular tradition, lowercase t. Got it. Sounds good? Okay.

[00:06:35] So important to remember Mary experienced a foretaste of salvation, born free from the stain of sin. She participates in the foretaste of how we're meant to be united with God, which is body and soul. That's the assumption. That's what you need to know about it. In a nutshell, you know, so much of Catholic tradition and dogma, you know. I am nothing if not succinct. It's true. Right. So this is the tale of the girdle of St. Thomas, the virgin's girdle, holy belt, sacra centola, sincture of the most holy, theotokos, and so on. There are lots of titles for this and it spans a lot of different cultures.

[00:07:06] It's been around since about the 4th or 5th century in writing. The way that it was written about lends many historians to believe that it was considered common knowledge and only came into popularity, so to speak, due to possibly heresies or fads at the time. It's really hard to tell, but very often we'll find, and I'll talk a little more about this a little later, but certain things kind of catapult into the public eye.

[00:07:31] You could probably see that now with like, for example, talks of like the ethical use of AI for Catholics, depending on like pressures of the time. So the way this was referenced in the writings we have, it was something that like everybody always knew, but we're specifically discussing now. Always knew as in quotes. Oh yeah, sorry. You can't see my fingers. You guys just have to hear. I'm going to need you to listen to my voice and figure out when I'm quoting things. Okay, I have to stop. Is there actually a holy girdle?

[00:07:59] Is there like a relic of the Blessed Virgin? Yes. And we'll talk about that too specifically. All right, cool. I'm jumping the gun. I know. Oh no, you're fine. I love the forward thinking. This helps out. So basically, like I said, it began to frequently be referenced in apocryphal works from the 5th to 8th century specifically. And that's when the Dormition legend really picked up steam for the Eastern Christians. Dormition being the sleep of Mary where she, yeah. You're so smart. Mary's such a smart guy.

[00:08:28] The Dormition, capital D, is the tradition. And again, this is actually not something Catholics are required one way to believe or another, but one, I guess, hypothesis is what you'd call it of Mary's assumption was that she didn't fully die. She fell asleep and was awoken and taken straight to heaven because that could be like one way we're meant to pass. The other, I forget what it's called. We don't talk about it as much because the holy girdle is pretty tied into like Eastern Christianity. Is that another pun? No, it's not. I didn't mean for it to be, but it was.

[00:08:59] Is the, basically, she died and was resurrected. So Pope John Paul II was a big proponent of that particular lane of thought because it kind of mirrors the way that Christ died and resurrected. And if we're meant to follow in Christ's footsteps, it might be that. But again, the idea behind the Dormition is Mary would have been spared that suffering as like the closest thing to like a preternatural woman would be on earth. It's interesting.

[00:09:23] I do love that tradition with the little T that she was spared death just because she was so important to Christ. Yeah, I think it's like if you can't protect your own mom, like what's the point? Just out of curiosity, have you ever read the book City of God by Saint, I can't remember, but she's from like the 15th century. The whole book's about the life of Mother Mary. No, I've not read it. I don't know if it's necessarily like everything is completely approved by the church or I don't know.

[00:09:50] But it was presented that she actually had the option whether she would die or not. And she chose to because of, like you said, she's like, my son, you know, died. I'm not going to presume to or something. Yeah, that's so interesting. Almost like... And she died of love. She basically couldn't stand to be separated anymore. From her son. Yeah. As a mom, I feel that. It's like lower, what do you call it? Lower case tea tradition.

[00:10:18] Like you're not required to believe it, but it is a really cool, rich thing that if you wanted to believe in or appeal to you, it's okay to like think of it very highly. But it shouldn't be something that if you found out tomorrow it was untrue would rock your faith. Hopefully that makes sense to people. Yeah. And the cool word for that is apocryphal. Like the writing you were talking about, that's my new like word of the day, which is basically, and it can mean different things, but for the sake of today's discussions, writings of dubious history, like of validity. History? History?

[00:10:47] It's possible. And apocryphal works can have pieces. Like you have, for example, the like apocryphal gospels and things that still have truth in them. Like they talk about Christ being the son of God, right? That part's still true regardless of if it's in the gospel of Mary Magdalene or the gospel of Luke, right? But the writing itself is of dubious origin, so we can't verify that it's canonical. So that's a fun word for something like city of God because you said you weren't sure if it's true or not. Yeah.

[00:11:14] And they don't require you to believe it, but it sure reads well and it makes it like, ah, sounds pretty true. Yeah. I can see that. I have to look it up because it feeds right into this. So here's the important thing that we want to get to for the tale of or the legend, the lowercase T, whatever we want to call it, of doubting Thomas in reverse. There are a couple of variations to the story, but there are always a few key consistent points. They always have to do with the assumption, right? Okay. First thing that happens, Mary's assumed.

[00:11:43] So here's one variation. During the assumption, either Thomas is running home to say goodbye to her from India because remember she was the mother to all after Christ died. So he went off to India to basically convert the masses. He heard she was dying. He runs, runs back and barely misses her assumption, death, dormition, whatever ended up happening. Right?

[00:12:04] The inverse of that, that is also equally like found in different writings, is that he is the only one to witness the actual assumption since Mary appears to him in person instead. Hmm. And that's the, the in reverse aspect. So like the resurrection of Christ, obviously the tale of down and Thomas, which maybe I should have gone over this is that he didn't believe Christ had risen from the dead because he didn't see it. So Mary and her feminine genius would invert this and make him be the only one to see her assumption and call on him to spread the word.

[00:12:34] Well, he clearly learned his lesson, right? Yes. Yeah. That's just such a mom thing to do. So again, because of her feminine genius, she knows that Thomas is skeptical in nature, so she leans over and during the assumption drops or hands her girdle to Thomas as physical proof of what happened. Okay. Right? Because Thomas required the physical proof, let him touch the sides and wounds of Christ. She gave him her girdle to say, see, yeah, I dropped it on your head while going into heaven. This one's mine. Peace. I'll see y'all later. I've never heard this one. This is good. Okay.

[00:13:04] Yeah. This is fascinating. This is a good story. It is good. So more on that later. You'll start seeing it everywhere now that we've brought it up. So again, sometimes she appears to him because she knows of his doubtful tendencies. Other times she inverts his doubting story by caring only to him. Those are kind of the two things. And in fact, in the Syriac version of the story, so like that part of the world, again, prior to their schism, all of this is rooted in the same faith. So before the fourth century, their traditions are tradition.

[00:13:30] But in that version of the story, Thomas actually has to convince the other apostles that she was assumed. So just a step further. Yeah, I was about to say, now the roles are really reversed. Yes. Isn't it ironic? Cue Alanis Morissette for everybody. So, okay. On to kind of the next part. Any questions, thoughts, concerns, or comments so far? We're all following okay? I'm riveted. Riveted. Perfect. This goes into what Chris was talking about. So where is the girdle now?

[00:14:01] There are several girdles. Oh, no. We have several potential contenders. I'm not sure anyone's required to personally align with one or another. I'm almost wondering, does it make sense to break really briefly before this and then get into like the different girdles? Is this like a good like cliffhanger for our listeners? Keep them hooked. I'm hooked. So we can take a break. We are, in Joe's words, riveted out here. So here's a preview.

[00:14:30] Here's your own little foretaste. There are at least three girdles we're going to go over today. We'll spend a little more time with one rather than the others, but I'm excited to share them all with you. So to answer your question from earlier, Chris, yes, there is a girdle to this day. Sweet. Faith and charity are key elements of life, but are they at the center of your financial decisions? With Knights of Columbus, you can pursue financial stability.

[00:14:59] But more importantly, you can do so in a way that is compatible with Catholic teaching. For more than 140 years, we have helped families guard their financial future with our array of life insurance products. We have expanded our offerings to include retirement annuities, long-term care insurance, and disability income insurance. Let your faith inspire your financial decisions. Terms and conditions apply.

[00:15:25] Learn more by calling Lance Jolly at 901-277-1023. All people of goodwill are invited to enjoy Christian hospitality at Our Lady Queen of Peace Retreat Center, nestled on 140 acres in Stanton, Tennessee, just 45 minutes from East Memphis. Our budget-friendly retreat center features 27 private bedrooms, a beautiful chapel, multiple meeting spaces for groups from 2 to 100, professional kitchen and dining room,

[00:15:51] miles of walking trails, and plenty of secluded spots indoors and outdoors for quiet contemplation. Our Lady Queen of Peace Retreat Center is also the ideal location for corporate planning sessions, team building, and large groups of every variety. And by the way, our facility has great Wi-Fi, allowing folks to unplug, refresh, then plug back in. Our Lady Queen of Peace Retreat Center was built for all of us to enjoy.

[00:16:14] To learn more, visit olqpretreats.com and contact Steve Frockia at 901-351-9832. Welcome back to Buttered Toast and the Holy Ghost. I'm Chris. I'm still Megan. Hey, still Megan. So remind us, we are talking about what today? So we are still talking about the girdle.

[00:16:42] And I wanted to shout out our listener specifically. I'm sorry I neglected to mention you by name earlier. Anna, thank you for sending us this request. I'm hoping this finds you well. And I just want to use that as kind of a jumping off point to if you guys have things you want to hear about, any other listeners besides Anna, who's doing a fantastic job, feel free to leave us like a voice memo. You can do that again online or you can email us, leave a message on Spotify. I mean, anyway, we are like obviously dying to hear from you. So don't be shy. Follow Anna's lead and we can do a show for you at this point.

[00:17:12] We're small enough that like we're taking requests. So for now, for now, right. You better get in while you can. That's right. This is an elusive opportunity. So thank you again, Anna, for sending us this one. It was fascinating. I'm so excited to talk a little more about it. Girdles. Three of them. Three of them. We're going to touch on three. In the Eastern tradition specifically, we're talking Eastern and Western tradition. And again, that Eastern would be Byzantine. Is it Syriac? Am I saying that right? I'm like so, I've only read that. Like Syria? I think so.

[00:17:43] Can someone like, can someone call Father Clark and tell him how to say, like how am I supposed to say this? I feel like I just like need him on speed dial. Like, can you tell me? Yes, that tradition. And so in Eastern tradition, we have the signature of the most holy Theotokos. Like obviously that's Greek. That would be mother of God, Theotokos, for those who are unfamiliar with that title. One of my favorite titles. Is it really? We could talk all the day about it. In the Eastern Orthodox Church and then the holy girdle of the Syriac Orthodox Church. Dude, that also, if you remember, I texted you out of the blue about like divine nature.

[00:18:13] It was because I learned about the Syriac Orthodox Church and why they split was related to debates over the nature of Jesus. Well, yeah, that was the schism, right? That was their schism. This is different than the great schism of Byzantine 1 in 1100. The Syriac schism occurred like in 458. Maybe that's why this became popular. I don't know. Huh. No. So that was sent me down a spiral. Anyway, so those two Eastern traditions. Thomas has a really special relation to Christians in the East.

[00:18:42] He's very much as highly celebrated saint in Eastern churches to this day. Okay. He's known through legend and tradition as the bringer of Christianity to the Eastern area. Okay. Like he traveled after Pentecost to India and the surrounding areas. So tradition states that he went to preach in Persia, Medes, the Parthians. So sorry if I'm butchering that. And then ultimately land in India.

[00:19:09] Like we referenced earlier, he scurried home to say goodbye to his mother. I did write in parentheses here for some reason, insert Fullmetal Alchemist reference. I'm assuming that has to do with the two prophets. Do you know what I'm talking about? Yeah. I think I know where you're going with that. You know, you have the two prophets in the East that did Alkahestrian Alchemy. Yes. Okay. Shing and... Yes. What is the name of Central? Oh, you hadn't asked me. I had no. It's the circle state. It's literally where everything happens.

[00:19:40] It's the circle state. It's Amestris. Amestris. Yeah. See, we know our anime. So for those of you who know, you know. Okay. So there are two well-known girdles in the East, the Sanctuary of the Theotokos, the Eastern Orthodox one. It's made of camel hair and it was translated, which again, we're learning so many new words to Constantinople during the reign of Emperor Justinian, who you might remember from our David the Dendrite episode. Same guy. Okay.

[00:20:08] So you call it translating when you're taking relics from one place to another. That's the verb you use. You don't transition them. That's a new phrase. And what I like about this one specifically is it was actually translated alongside, I think it was, it was another big name one, like either the Ten Commandments or the Ark of the Covenant. Like it was a really big one. So the idea is it was translated with other things. Because of how important it was, clearly. Spoiler alert. This is the one I think I, if I were a vetting woman, I like this one the best because it's

[00:20:38] the oldest one. Okay. Okay. But again, you can choose to venerate any, really it's probably more about venerating the idea of it than mother. Is this actually the literal one? I don't know. So again, Emperor Justinian, whom we actually talked about during the David the Dendrite episode, this was around the fourth or fifth century. So this is again the earliest one. So again, made of camel hair, which sounds terribly uncomfortable. It might not have been, maybe they spun it. I don't know.

[00:21:02] But it was legendarily also said to be woven by the Virgin Mother herself so she would have made it. It was braided later on with gold by Byzantine Empress Zoe circa 1899 after it purportedly granted her a miraculous cure. To what? I don't know. It didn't say. I guess woman issues. We'll go there. That's probably a pretty good bet. They're very private about it. It's an empress. I don't know. So that is a good question.

[00:21:28] The second option we have from the East is the sincture venerated by the Syriac Orthodox Church. It's known as the Holy Sunaro or sincture, allegedly taken from the grave of St. Thomas in India. So it's actually held in segments. I could not figure out why. One notable thing about it was that it was held in its own special church that was actually damaged during the Syrian civil war and barely survived.

[00:21:54] But so there are little segments or pieces of it chopped up and sent all over the region so you can venerate it in multiple places. Okay. So those are the two Eastern options. And again, I'm in, I'm a favor of the sincture of the Theotokos. And this might probably my number one if I were going to rank them. It's got the cooler of the two names. So we do have a really cool one in Catholic Western tradition though. So I'll spend a little more time on that because there was a lot in this one that we can unpack. And it's technically the Catholic relic to this day that you can go venerate. Hmm.

[00:22:21] So this legend of the Dormition of the Assumption. Wait, sorry. Did the, the sincture of the Theotokos, did that get lost with the? No, we have it, but it's in possession of the Eastern Orthodox Church. Okay. Okay. Right. I must've missed that. Yeah. So it isn't started in the fourth or fifth century. It's still in possession of the Eastern Orthodox Church to this day. That would again be part of our shared histories. I don't, maybe someone can write it and correct me if wrong. I don't see any reason why you couldn't venerate that because you have to think before we split, we were one church.

[00:22:50] So like the 1100s. I really don't see a reason why you couldn't. Yeah. We talked about the David the Dendrite too. Like he's their saint. He's our saint. It's everybody's saints. A lot of the saints are shared. Yeah. That's what I mean. There's like so much rich tradition. It feels like really sad that we can't hold over like one little word in the creed. What's the big deal? Just one little word. It's fine. It's just, they should have gotten over it. So they should have seen things our way. So all that to say, those are the two Eastern ones. So then we're going to jump to Western because this is probably the one I have the most info

[00:23:20] on because the most was readily available when I was researching it. So this legend of Dormition, Assumption, et cetera, would be well known in the region of Italy by the 14th century. This is when the records or the chronological like girdle story starts. We've confirmed it around the 14th century Italy and that's really important. And so that's where we're going to see a lot of the Western traditions, et cetera, that I'm going to talk about later. That actually is the thing I'm most excited about with this story.

[00:23:48] So this is the only one in the West. We don't have multiple traditional ones. This is it. It lives in Prado, Italy, which you can think of as just north of Florence. Okay. I feel like we've talked about Prado, Italy before. I'm sure we have. There's like a lot that goes on in that area of the world. It's like Italy is kind of important to the church for some reason. Nobody knows why it's a mystery, really. Anyway, you can visit this bad boy, bad girl. I don't know what the phrase would be. At Capella del Sacro Chingolo. Okay.

[00:24:17] I had to write that down phonetically. So Capella del Sacro Chingolo, right, would be the Italian. Your Italian is better than mine. My Italian is terrible. And so this Prado girdle is considered by many to be the most compelling girdle in Western tradition. Specifically, it beat out many competing girdles, which is actually just a phrase I wanted to get into the show because it's really funny to say. Competing girdles. You're picturing them all like you're whiffing them at each other. You're like fighting. I actually kind of think about them in a race. Yeah. And so here's where it gets fun.

[00:24:47] We even have one that was quite possibly paid for by the city of Siena, which was a rival city to Florence that would be competing or trying to beat out Florence slash Prado for the commercial and mercantile benefits of pilgrimage to see the girdle. So they looked at it like this is a real moneymaker. Let's get in on the girdle game. And so they had their own competing girdle that I could not find anything about. Sadly, I wanted to know more. Like, how do you decide which one's the right one? I have no idea. I'm going to trust people smarter than me figured it out.

[00:25:18] So sometimes the girdle would get conflated with tertiary relics. That's our third really nice word for day, meaning third class relics as in relics that were touched the original girdle. So if I took my own sanctuary and touched it to the girdle, I now have a third class relic. This works also for like saints bones and stuff. So when you buy like a relic online, you can actually sell third class relics, which I didn't know. But you can sell something that touched a saint, but you couldn't sell a piece of saint. Right. That's the difference. Just a real quick lesson on relics.

[00:25:46] First class relic is a piece of the saint themselves. A second class relic is something that touched the saint. So their clothes, their shoes, personal possessions, et cetera. And then third class relics, like Megan just said, are items that touched a first class relic. Yeah. So you could take like a rosary and touch it to an uncorruptible saint and you have a third class relic. Which you probably can't because they're behind glass. You can't touch them anymore.

[00:26:15] But back in the day when we did this regularly. Really? So, okay. A beating girdle. One famous tertiary relic that we know of that would get conflated sometimes historically with the Prado girdle was one purchased by like Elizabeth of York, the Queen to Henry VII. She became enamored with the girdle when she found out it could help with like pregnancy issues, with woman issues and really wanted a baby. And so she took special interest in getting help with that, which she ultimately did. So there must be something to it. Maybe it's tertiary one. I don't know.

[00:26:44] But I just love that story. It's amazing how often like the royalty is like involved in church stuff. It's almost as if there was a history of that or Chris is making a face at me. He's twitching. So, okay. The Prado's girdle ownership, right? It's a lot of words. Um, this, this is actually the first paragraph that was traced to a merchant named Michelle who received it from his bride who was from Jerusalem that traced her family's ownership

[00:27:06] of the girdle, um, back to a Eastern priest that inherited it directly from St. Thomas after his death. Whoa. What? So my cousin's sister's boyfriend. Six degrees of separation, and I have this really holy item. Yes. So again, you had a merchant named Michelle who received the girdle from his bride, who said it was passed down through her family, that she traced that ownership back to an Eastern priest in service of St. Thomas. Again, Eastern, right?

[00:27:36] That's where Thomas was and where he would have died, right? If you go see the tomb, who gave him the girdle as inheritance, basically. That's a really long time. That's the Prado chronological order. So a cathedral, obviously, needed to be built to safeguard the girdle. This happened after an attempted theft around 1312. And the economic impact of the girdle, like we mentioned earlier, was so great

[00:28:02] that the city council decided they needed to elect a body of four laypersons called the Opera della Sacra Singiolo. Note, opera translates into work, right, in Italian, who they appointed by the city basically to govern all things related to the girdle and the pilgrimage it produced. Right? That's how big, like one relic's impact people were pouring in. I could see why Sienna was like, let's get in on that game. Yeah, no kidding. So can you imagine putting it on your resume?

[00:28:29] I was a member of the opera that oversaw the girdle. I guarded the girdle. Yeah. So just basically anything, I guess, fiduciary, they were in charge of it. So now that we're familiar with all the girdles out there in the world, let's talk about the tradition appearing in art. This is important because Prado is located north of the Tuscany province of Italy, right? It protects Florence. Florence took control of Prado like 1350-ish, right? So we have a cathedral. It's all built. It's everything.

[00:28:59] During that time, Tuscany was at war with Milan, okay? Florence was meant to be protected by Prado. So, right, Florence is the capital of Tuscany. But the troops went around Prado and started to siege Florence directly. But they gave up the siege on the Feast of the Assumption. It's thought by historians that the government of Florence would be so relieved and grateful for this, it would make sense for them to commission a huge number of Florentine artists

[00:29:27] to help create pieces specifically depicting the Assumption and the girdle in gratitude of what was seen to be an intercession from the Virgin Mother. Hence, we have a Florentine boom of Assumption-related art around 1351, a year or two after this attempted siege. Okay. In fact, another Milanese duke later on attempted to conquer Florence in 1401. This time we have a record of the people actually processing the girdle around the city,

[00:29:54] which indeed caused the duke to turn back and stop his attack on Florence. So, we have at least, like, we're at least, like, one victory in the name of the girdle specifically. Right. It's thought they may have done the same in the past, but we don't have a record of it. So, I don't feel comfortable saying, like, we did it twice. So, at this time, this is what I found fascinating, and this is a thing, Joe, that you're going to see everywhere. You will see a plethora of reliefs, paintings, and sculptures from this time, this high Italian Renaissance, from this time to the high Italian Renaissance, right,

[00:30:23] around the 1500s, that in most Marian art, you're going to see her with a girdle, first and foremost. We all can visualize, right? You have the tunic, the girdle, and the veil. I want to make sure we're talking about the same one. It's just sort of that cloth that drapes across the bottom, right? So, you know altar servers? They have that sancture. Well, what do you mean, sancture? Like the rope. Okay, the rope. So, you picture an altar server or a priest or a monk might be easier. You know, you have, like, the brown robe. Yeah, like St. Francis has them. St. Francis. He has a girdle. He's wearing a girdle. It's the, it's the sancture.

[00:30:53] Oh, the rope. See, I've been thinking of a piece of fabric that, like, an apron or something. That's a good call out. I didn't think about it. I got so lost in girdle world, Joe. I forgot that people don't use that word. Yeah, because girdle, well, girdle is, you know, female from the, what? My mom probably wore a girdle when she was a teenager. But we can do sancture if that's easier for people. It's a rope. It's a rope. I say the rope. Yeah, okay. So, picture Mother Mary. Everyone's seen her, whether you're Catholic or not. You have the veil, right? And then you have the long tunic. And then you have that rope. That's what we're talking about.

[00:31:22] Okay, now we're talking. Okay, gotcha. So, at this time, that's important. Because in the art, you will always see her painted with that sancture. And that's important because it, like most pieces of sacred art, has a meaning behind it. It almost always relates back to, like, chastity, right? The fullness of love in oneself. And whatever state of life one is in, your love is ordered. It is pure and it is holy. Right. Yep. So, not only do we see this girdle, these girdles features in the paintings, you're going to start seeing a ton of depictions of St. Thomas receiving the girdle.

[00:31:52] Particularly, like I said, in this Italy High Renaissance period between 13th and 16th century. And so, if you see a painting or a sculpture or a leaf of the Assumption around this time and in this region, you're almost guaranteed to see an awkward little St. Thomas in the corner. What? Chris is miming it, too. Ready to receive the girl from heaven. That is a direct retelling of this tradition. That's awesome. An Italian person would have looked at that and known exactly what it's depicting. I never even noticed it.

[00:32:19] But dang it, if I didn't go look back at some of my favorite Renaissance pieces of the Assumption, there he is in every single one of her leaning over and dropping it to him. And I didn't put together that's what it was. No, I'm going to go look that up. There are so many. I found so many in Germany. And then also, in Eastern tradition, we talked about your Byzantine art episode, Chris. We talked about icons. There are a ton of icons made in that tempura stuff that we talked about, too. I don't remember if that's the right word. But of Mary dropping the girdle. That's incredible.

[00:32:48] Because it's an Eastern tradition. So I love that. So next time you're thinking about the Assumption, which you absolutely can because we have the Feast of the Assumption coming up in August, I want you to picture St. Thomas kneeling awkwardly in the corner just ready to catch that rope. I love it. So this is kind of where I wanted to conclude things. I know we've talked a lot about girdles. I'm glad that Joe reminded me to define what a girdle is. And I wanted to point out that we do have the Feast of the Assumption coming up on August 15th.

[00:33:15] And this is your official reminder that it is a holy day of obligation. And so now none of you have an excuse to miss mass that day. You all have to go. Plan accordingly. Plan accordingly. So that is the tradition of St. Thomas, doubting Thomas in reverse, the holy girdle, the holy sanctuary, the sanctuary of the Holy Theotokos, the sanctuary of the Virgin. I could go on and on. But what do we think? I love it. I think that's really cool.

[00:33:41] I think St. Thomas has gotten a bum rap because all we think of him is, you know, he does all this great stuff in his whole career. And yet all we think of is the whole doubting Thomas. But with this situation, it sounds like he was actually fully, you know, he learned his lesson. Yeah. He'd been out doing missionary work and he was so convinced he hustled home. Which isn't an easy thing to do to go from India to what? To Greece. I thought she died in Greece.

[00:34:10] Well, I don't know. She actually has two tombs or two tombs of Mary. And curiously, neither of them have a body in them. I wonder why. I wonder why. It's hard to tell. You guys always I always learn something on the show. I have to say. That's good. I really, really love this. And again, your challenge, everybody's homework is to go look at pictures of the assumption from the Florentine artists. Or you can just Google the high Renaissance period and you're going to see every single one of a man. And sometimes sometimes it's literally just Mary and Thomas. OK. Right.

[00:34:39] Very often you're painted with all like I know you're picturing one of the assumption on all the like apostles are looking up at her. And again, you're going to have Thomas in a specific position to catch the girl. But I've seen some that were just Thomas and Mary. And I found depictions in Germany randomly. It's very popular there. I don't know why. That was the other place. That was the other hotspot if we were mapping it. A lot of the ones I saw just from a brief Google search. Did you Google it? Just had a. So curious. The little angels, the cherubs that, you know, they have their heads in the clouds.

[00:35:09] Like not figuratively speaking, like literally the clouds are their heads. So I'll need to I'll need to search a little bit deeper. But I'll send you some. Yeah. We'll use some art obviously for the cover on this so you guys can all see it too. So. But dude, man, it's great to be back in the saddle and to hear from everybody. And I've missed doing this. So I'm excited to be able to share. Yeah. Something else with everybody. So let me close it out with a couple of quick reminders. As always, you can find more at Memphis Catholic Radio dot com.

[00:35:39] We have a library of shows, not just ours, but others like ours. So feel free to peruse that. Please reach out to us again. We love those voicemails. Those voice memos are so impactful. It's probably our favorite way to receive requests or informations or thought feedback, whatever. Joe wanted me to remind everybody in case you're a little intimidated by leaving a voice memo. You can absolutely do a do over. You can go and like re-recorded if you're not happy with it. We don't get that luxury. So you're going to hear lots of squeaking or random sounds or like mispronounced words.

[00:36:06] Words I'll never be able to take back if I'm saying Syriac incorrectly. Like you guys have all heard me say that 10 times. It's out there on the Internet forever. But you get a do over when you leave a memo. Yeah, it's important because, you know, as you're recording, you might get intimidated and hang up, but just you could do it 50 times till you get it right. Yeah. And it's just us. Leave us a leave us. Yeah. Who cares? We care. Send us a message. Reach out to us. We're always looking for patrons and sponsors. Zaxby's, you can sponsor us if you hear this. We didn't get you for dinner again tonight. If not, if you're a local Memphis, we would love to hear from you.

[00:36:36] And thanks again for listening to Buttered Toast and the Holy Ghost. There it is.